making it the most expensive work of art ever auctioned.
My question : Do you think some people have too much money ? Feel free to elaborate.
making it the most expensive work of art ever auctioned.
My question : Do you think some people have too much money ? Feel free to elaborate.
gottawonder Loves her tortoise!
I’m not sure what the solution is to poverty. It isn’t a lack of resources, because there is enough food to meet everyone’s needs, but it never seems to be distributed to the poor.
War is often the real culprit in poverty, because it drives people off of their land, armies often steal food, burn farms, and kill livestock, and drive farm families into refugee camps where they can’t grow food for themselves or others. Then the armies make sure that food doesn’t reach the refugees.
There is poverty in countries like Canada, but it is often RELATIVE poverty. They often still have a place to live, food, water, access to health care, but they don’t have any money for a car, nicer clothes, etc.
A lot of people in Canada who live below the poverty line would still be considered fortunate by a lot of people in, say, India.
My husband and I likely do have a thousand times more money than a lot of people in the world. I’m not willing to give up my money to equalise things. I could give some of it, but how does one decide how much I should give?
Isn’t that what taxes is? A fairly large chunk of our income goes towards paying for roads, schools, hospitals and so on, that people who live below the poverty line (and don’t pay taxes) may use.
Communism tries to answer such questions, but people just aren’t good enough to make real communism work. Real communism (each according to his needs and abilities, and public ownership of property) would require that people would still strive to be things like doctors, but without getting more pay than say, a farmer or a laboror. It would also mean that people really worked to their full potential, and as hard as they normally would, with only the valorous belief that they were helping the common good.
There would have to be no exploitation of public property by individuals (for example, one farmer grazing a thousand cattle on a public pasture and driving away the other farmers), and so on.
I don’t like any kind of extreme and as I said, I believe in freedom and the state not owning everything. But where there are no laws or loose laws, there should be basic principles. I think there’s a fair distance between being disgusted by the excesses of a liberal economy and being a communist. Sure, a doctor who studied hard (and has a tough job involving life and death) should earn a decent living, sure, an employer has more responsibilities than an employee and should therefore earn more, but merit is often used as the justification for all kinds of crazy incomes with nothing to do with merit.
Reminds me of this story from last week : a guy at my work joked in the elevator that he earns 4000 euros in two weeks (not that there’s anything wrong with that). He then realised that everyone in the same elevator earned about a thousand a month and must have gotten uncomfortable, so as to justify it he said “well, we (= the receptionists) work very hard”. Which actually was a worse thing to say, go tell someone who cleans other people’s poo for a living that they don’t work hard. My repartee was an easy one, President Sarkozy had infamously said on the same week that he wanted to do a parallel celebration on workers day for “the real workers”, so I could not not kid him saying : “so I guess that means on may 1, you’re going to that other party ?”. Which reminds me I must get dressed and go vote today ;)
gottawonder Loves her tortoise!
why some jobs are so incredibly over valued. Why a plastic surgeon makes so much more money than a family doctor. Why the person who works as a receptionist for a law firm makes more money than a librarian, or why everyone in the world makes more money than a stock clerk or a janitor.
I realise that some jobs are just more high profile, and even if your actual job isn’t really harder, the amount of money involved in your decision is much larger, and in some cases safety is an issue (like designing a safe building or road, or a safe car).
I used to be a janitor though, and I made minimum wage for a physically strenous job, with a surprising amount of accountability, and access to a lot of important things. It should have paid MINIMUM of twice what I was making, considering that I had to work nights, often alone, and the work was exhausting.