I need to be more specific about exactly what I want to be able to do. My goals for learning to play the piano are:

1. To be able to sight read intermediate-level pieces respectably (i.e. with reasonable accuracy and speed)
2. Have the technical ability to play things like Bach 2 and 3 part inventions, French and English Suites, and WTC at correct tempo and w/o making many mistakes
3. Learn the technical things I never really learned like tremolo, grace notes, and pedaling
4. Work on musicianship (dynamics, legato/staccato, phrasing, etc.). These are things I usually ignore since I’m just trying to get the right notes out.

I think I’m going to start contacting some teachers. I’m emailing one right now.