catherineaq is editing herself. [I won't share your 43T; PLEASE don't share mine.]

go to church (read all 18 entries…)
ack!

I swear, I read the bulletins & websites carefully and the two Catholic churches in town start religious ed. in first grade.

So why did E come home the other day listing off four kids in his class of only fifteen who are having first communion? Huh? He’s in kindergarten! When I was a kid we did first communion as second graders.

Today’s bulletin said registration for fall religious ed. is now starting, so I mentioned to him that it will be time for him to start. I said that I am doing my best to explain things to him, but they will know how to explain it better for kids to understand. (At the same time I know I’ll be checking with him each week to see what they teach him so I can help him understand or so I can “spin” the message if I don’t like their take on it.) He didn’t seem enthused, but really wants to have First Communion. Go figure. Wants to be like the other kids.

This discussion followed me answering him when he asked why some people walk right out after getting communion. Once when I was in college, the priest launched into a diatribe after a number of people did this. Of course, we who were still there to hear it were not the guilty ones . . . anyway, in answering E, I had a really hard time saying that the communion wafer is literally the body of Christ. I’m more comfortable with metaphor, but I know that’s not what I’m supposed to believe. Also there were flyers around encouraging us to be strong supporters of marriage. (Legislators vote here in MA on Wed., apparently, in some step toward keeping or removing the legalization of gay marriage.) Why, when I have so much discomfort with so much that’s said and done by the church, do I also draw back in alarm at the thought of just rejecting it and walking away? I do believe the church can/will change, but slowly. Very, very, slowly. Maybe staying in and keeping my liberal beliefs and raising my son to be a critical thinker and loving person will help hasten the change.



Comments:

little_terry be happy.

kindergarten?

One of my coworker’s kids is more like 7 or 8 and just had his first communion. For pete’s sake, kindergartners can barely write their names. Can you imagine trying to get a group of them to understand the basics of what’s expected of them in a communion class? (or whatever they’re called, sorry) Maybe the churches are losing too many families before the kids get to 7 years?

You’ve got a hard task in front of you, but if you can resolve these issues for yourself, hopefully you can help E figure them out too? It seems like the most important aspect in and outside the church would be empathy and compassion for others, and I’m confident you can teach him that…

catherineaq is editing herself. [I won't share your 43T; PLEASE don't share mine.]

after posting, I looked it up

on the parish website, and I’m right: it’s second grade. So I don’t know what E is talking about. Maybe some other Christian denomination does it younger?

“If you can resolve these issues for yourself”: Yes, that’s the big “if”! I think where I am right now is wanting the support of organized religion to encourage me in loving unselfishness (and that sort of thing), because I know I have a tendency to drift (in any aspect of my life) if not prompted to focus by some outside influence. So, I will probably continue to be unceasingly angsty about specific beliefs, but I can only think it’s all to the good if I reflect and examine instead of accepting blindly, right? And I think I really want E to have familiarity with this religion that is his heritage, and if he rejects it later in a reasoned way, I can accept that. But this way he has an informed choice (and as you know from past posts, the “informed” will include more than just Catholicism). I know that for some, being raised completely outside religion has left them feeling confused and excluded, and they wish they had it as a touchstone.

And that’s more clarity than I’ve had yet on this topic! Thanks for prompting me to muse.


catherineaq has gotten 2 cheers on this entry.

 

I want to:
43 Things Login