become fluent in Finnish (read all 28 entries…)
Imperative 2 years ago

Ok… a possibly heavy question coming up.

Why does an imperative have a weak consonant? Is there some secret forgotten closed ending on the verb?

Example:

kirjoittaa = to write
kirjoitan = I write (-n is a closed ending, so tt -> t)
he kirjoittivat = they wrote (-vat = open, so tt is ok)

but…

kirjoita! = write!

On this word, there is no ending, so I would assume tt not t.

Aha

Ok… while writing this, I’ve discovered the answer for myself, but I’ll leave it here for my own memory…

So, it seems that an imperative ends in -k BUT the -k has been lost over time. So you have:

kirjoitak – closed syllable, therefore tt -> t

...and miss the k, gives…

kirjoita

So I guess my original question “Is there some secret forgotten closed ending on the verb?” was absolutely spot on.

I’m quite pleased with myself, because I spotted this from changing my google mail into Finnish, and at the bottom it said “Hanki Google Mail puhelimeesi. Se on erittäin nopea.”

I couldn’t find the dictionary form for Hanki, then discovered it was Hankkia… and that’s how it all started.



Comments:

Your questions are too hard

Stu

Your language is too hard

:)

Sorry… I know that Finnish is logical, so if I see something that doesn’t seem logical I know there’s a hidden answer there, and I have to find out.

I guess it won’t help me chatting in the street, but I’m a curious kind of guy!

I really didn’t expect an answer to this one… just like I don’t think I’d be able to answer if someone asked me about medieval English (well, unless it was about yogh of course)

I can't see much logicalness in Finnish(!)

The only possibility is either to adopt the ear for Finnish of to have it already. Hehee.

I can say “Keksijä keksi keksiä keksin keksimättömäksi” but for me it takes time to understand what “I wonder whether the wether will weather the weather, or whether the wether the weather will kill”. Languages are tricky.

I learn every time something new when you post entries about Finnish language :D And I suppose to be fluent in Finnish :P

I guess I just speak and write it, I don’t really understand the reasons :) You are doing so well!

Or should I say: erittäin hienoa Stu! :)


Stu has gotten 2 cheers on this entry.

 

I want to:
43 Things Login