Dave is considering coming back to 43T

live my one wild and precious life (read all 43 entries…)
Thinking about John Locke 15 months ago

I know, we all think about John Locke all the time, right?

I’m reading a book about James Madison, and the writing of the US Constitution and the Bill of Rights. Madison was the author of both the Virginia plan, which was the basis for our system of government, as well as the wording of the Bill of Rights which was submitted as the first ten amendments to the constitution. Pretty amazing accomplishments, and more important than being the Fourth president, for which he is most remembered, IMHO.

But the book also describes a social pariah named Col. George Mason, the next door neighbor to George Washington. In May of 1776, Mason wrote the “Virginia Declaration of Rights”, on which Madison’s Bill of rights is based. Not only that, but he was sent to Congress in June of 1776 to demand the Congress issue a declaration of independence, based on the rights of government in Mason’s Declaration. When Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence, he drew on two significant pieces of scholarship; Mason’s Declaration and Locke’s principles, on which Mason’s Declaration of Rights is based.

So why don’t we know who George Mason is? Well, when Madison refused Mason’s proposal to add a Bill of Rights to the Constitution, Mason said he could not sign the document without one. His refusal to sign the constitution, after working so hard on it for four months with the other delegates, caused his fall from favor with George Washington. And that erased his place in history.

So it goes like this;

1) Most world governments are modeled after the US Constitution, the Declaration of Independence, or the English Bill of rights, written in 1689 by Locke.

2) The Constitution, Declaration of Independence and Bill of Rights are based on the writings of George Mason in the Virginia Declaration of Rights.

3) Mason also based his work on the writings of English Bill of Rights, but with more consideration for Locke’s other writings such as the “Letter Concerning Toleration” and the “Second Treatise on Government.”

4) So if all these great men were refining the ideas of the man before him, where did Locke come up with the original treatise on government that started it all? Surely he didn’t lock his door and write it in an afternoon. He must have drawn from other documents as well.

So my next quest is to figure out where Locke’s notion of the Natural Law and Rights of Man came from.



Comments:

influences

I’d first look at Descartes as an early positive influence, then to negative influences, such as Hobbes, whom Locke was opposed to, opposition which helped Locke form his ideas.

Later it would have been other contemporaries and friends of his who influenced and informed his ideas, like Newton and Dryden.

I can’t help but wonder whether his training and practice as a physician, among other modern physicians, helped form some of practical outlook, and also his humanity and focus on human rights.

I think he was very much a man of the then modern era, and wasn’t much interested in looking to the past for direction.

Dave is considering coming back to 43T

Descartes, Hobbes, and... the Iroquois?

Thanks for the great feedback, Catherine. I’m as surprised that anyone read my post to the end, much less had the insight to comment on the next direction of my research.

I agree that Descartes had influenced Locke, and that, in fact, Locke draws heavily from Hobbes, although he doesn’t attribute him for obvious reasons.

But in my mind, the thing that moves Locke from the simple social contract philosophy of the Romans as popularized by Hobbes, is the striking departure from the need for authoritarian government and his passion for liberty and equality. These seem truly new, in 1689. Except…

I did find the text of the Great Law of Peace to be startlingly reminiscent of the constitution and the bill of rights, and it clearly predates Locke 200 years or more.

Some scholars point to this, and not to Locke, as the inspiration of Franklin and Madison. This is why I found the link from Mason to Madison so interesting; Mason was clearly translating Locke into an actionable document when he wrote the Virginia Declaration.

So there are two possible threads to get to our concept of Liberty and Government. I am used to thinking only of the Eurocentric thread, but now I’m wondering if Locke could have drawn from the Iroquois as well as Hobbes to create his political philosophy. After all, Locke goes on quite a bit about America and the liberty of the Indians.

Anyway, thanks for your suggestions. I have been avoiding reading Hobbes, but I think Leviathan has gone onto my reading list.


Dave has gotten 1 cheer on this entry.

  • bp cheered this 15 months ago

 

I want to:

The world wants to...

43 Things Login