You surprise me with the violence of your advice. In other comments I’ve seen you be sarcastic, even acidic, but I always thought there was a decent reason behind what you said. I thought you were trying to get people to think, when they had only been emotional and irrational.
Your advice in this case is irrational. It seems that you are calling her boyfriend a very mean name, and suggesting that he deserves an injury, just because he is afraid of the graveyard. Hurting him will not likely cure him of his fear, however, nor will it help this girl have a better relationship. She may be fine with the fact that he has this particular fear. Having a good relationship is all about learning to deal with each others’ faults, not about power-plays, violence, and trying to control other people into being “perfect”.
I have to believe that you were only trying to be funny, but it wasn’t funny. It was uncalled-for and rude, and didn’t even have a good point.
It is sociopathic to think it’s okay to inflict violence on a man just because he cries or feels afraid of something. I hope that’s not who you really are.