at last — 1 year ago
finished all five books of The Once and Future King. Overall, I must admit to being disappointed. The Sword in the Stone has been butchered and nothing that comes after justifys the changes (apparently he swapped things around to adopt the first book to the series).
The Witch in the Wood (book II) has some very disturbing images – the cat being boiled alive, the children slaughtering a unicorn… and while they do create a mood and are quite unforgettable, the author seems to dwell on the details in a way quite un-necessary to the plot. Also a lot of smug racist comments about Celts and Gaels…. from the blurb at the end it seems this was a reaction to his life at the time of writing and he was indeed going through a period of hating all things Irish.
The Ill-Made Knight (book III) my favourite of the five. The standard list of Lancelots adventures and saving of various maidens was a little drawn out, but the developing relationship between Guinevere, Arthur and Lancealot is very nicely done.
The Candle in the Wind(book IV) Some really nice narrative bits, lots of good background history, and the gathering doom around the main protagonists kept me going through this book, but the philosophical struggle of Arthur and his might vs right arguements, which go on for entire chapters, made most of the story skipworthy!
The Book of Merlyn (book V) I have no idea what TH White was trying to do here. He has Merlin visit Arthur on the eve of his final battle, the king is old, weary and despairing, and Merlin promptly whisks him off to a conference of animals who all abuse humans, tell him his race is doomed and everything he struggled for during his life is pointless, transform him into a young man again and send him off to repeat almost word for word two episodes from book I – the visits to the ants and the geese (both additions to the first book in place of much better pieces), then he is turned back into an old man again and killed in battle the next day.
