My career is currently devoted to the actuality, not the genre. Slowly, inexorably, I am losing fascination with the “good guy” end of it. There are no longer “good” and “bad” guys in the world – just people with different agendas, different anger levels, and certain affinities for conniving, cheating, and mayhem. and some are writers
A couple of books – “A Million Little Pieces” and “My Friend Leonard” by James Frey came out in the last couple of years, in the style of Truman Capote’s “In Cold Blood”. Posing as true crime, they are actually fictionalized fact. Unlike Capote, Frey is not apparently manipulating the life and death of anyone else, although not even that is clear. The books are entertainingly written, drag the reader deep into the writer’s strange world of maleficence, and were passed off initially as biographical. It is an interesting exercise to read the books, then wonder how they would have done in the genre to which they rightfully belong – fiction. The truth of the matter is that Frey was unable to sell the story as fiction. Why should it make a difference? And Frey did it not just once, but twice!
An interesting contrast and compare read is something I picked up in the airport for my journey this week: “The Birthday Party A Memoir of Survival”, by Stanley Alpert.
Alpert was not the survivor of an airline crash, or drug addiction (as is Frey), but of a mugging. Although most people do survive muggings, especially ones where they are not beaten or stabbed or shot, Alpert’s mugging was worth a Penguin True Crime publication. And it has to be because he has a sort of Woody Allen style to his tale. Imagine how Allen would spin the loss of his credit cards to a threatening gun toting gang on the streets of New York City who take him for a ride while they try to figure out how to get at his six figure bank account, and you’ve got the picture.
The more interesting part from my point of view is the police reaction to his tale of woe, once he has gotten through the main part of the survival mentioned in the title.
Alpert assures us that his story is true, only mildly reconstructed, as he must rely on memory for dialogue. It is interesting, again, to compare this with Capote’s style, where he relies on his memory as well, claiming to have 94% recall.
So, if you, like me, have an interest in true crime stories, this set of novels/crime stories make for a provocative reading palette.