This novel is simple, but the descriptions are lush and realistic, the characters interesting, the setting unique for a classic. The balance between the male narrator and female subject worked well for Cather. I tend to read more Southern and British literature, and very few things set on the prairie, it’s not a place I am naturally drawn to. But My Antonia made the prairie come alive to me, full of beauty and very hard work. I enjoyed it a great deal and wondered why I hadn’t read it before, the content is very appropriate for a young adult reader and it seems like it would be a good fit for a high school literature class. (9/10)
kris10s's Life List
-
1. Glorify God and enjoy him forever
1 entry . 50 cheers87 people -
2. be an excellent wife and mother
1 entry . 37 cheers5 people -
3. understand and practice true hospitality
1 entry . 25 cheers6 people -
4. learn to speak another language -- any language!
1 entry . 24 cheers17 people -
5. write and publish a book
1 entry . 17 cheers776 people -
6. go to europe
1 entry . 16 cheers2,484 people -
7. Go to graduate school
1 entry . 17 cheers1,191 people -
8. eat healthier
1 entry . 11 cheers10,142 people -
9. drink more water
1 entry . 9 cheers18,982 people -
10. go organic
2 entries . 33 cheers121 people -
11. volunteer as a breastfeeding educator
1 entry . 17 cheers1 person -
12. memorize the Heidelberg Catechism
1 entry . 8 cheers3 people -
13. learn to dive
1 entry . 11 cheers240 people -
14. be a better listener
1 entry . 9 cheers752 people -
15. knit a sweater
1 entry . 12 cheers773 people -
16. get published
1,996 people -
17. read 52 books in 2009
3 entries . 1 cheer19 people -
18. have better posture
1 entry . 2 cheers7,730 people -
19. learn to smock
1 entry20 people
About 3 or 4 of the books I read every year are actually unabridged audio books we listen to on road trips. The night before we left for North Carolina, I made a whirlwind trip to the library with the girls to grab a few possibilities Michael and I might enjoy. I remembered that Michael appreciated Allende’s House of Spirits, so I grabbed this one. There was no time to even read the back that day, so as we started listening, I was really confused. After a while, I realized this was a Young Adult novel, part of a trilogy that Allende wrote in the genre. Once that came to light, I tried to appreciate this for what it was. The plot had a great deal of potential but I was disappointed that it seemed like the protagonists, unlike their adult counterparts, didn’t find their way through the mystery and adventure by wit or strength but rather depended on their magical “totemic powers.” Overall, not a bad story, but Allende seemed slightly condescending in her writing for a YA audience. I’d still like to read her adult novels, though! (6/10)
