A few years ago, after many late night confidential diatribes concerning lazy husbands, my best friend and I decided to engage in an experiment. We had frittered away months and many gripe sessions about the lack of domestic involvement with our respective husbands, and had decided the time for action was upon us. Both of us had waited until our mid 20’s to get married, and we had found men who had been established personally and professionally prior to meeting us. This was highly attractive in the beginning: both of our husbands lived alone, cooked and cleaned for themselves, had great careers—they were virtual paragons of masculine maturity.
And then a funny thing happened. We got married. And one day not long after, I woke up to find myself folding his tighty-whities, ladling his meals onto our wedding china. I started feeling a whole lot like my mother, and less like a woman of the new millennium, a woman in an “equal opportunity” household I had envisioned creating.
Ironically, my best friend seemed to be suffering from the same fate. This wonderful man she had walked down the aisle with mere months before was now what she referred to as a “couch slug,” an amoeba-like organism incapable of picking his smelly socks off of the floor, and prone to grunting requests for meatloaf dinners and beers out of the fridge. We pondered how we found ourselves in such stereotypical marriages. We fought, begged, cajoled with our husbands for more help around the house, only to find ourselves picking up the laundry or cooking a meal at the end of a work day. We initiated and staged insurrections, rebellions from housework, only to find that our husbands seemed relatively unfazed by the laundry piling up and the ring around the bathtub.
And then, one crisp autumn day, my best friend and I attended an Ohio State football game, and stood around tailgating in our scarlet and grey before the game, lamenting our usual litany of marital grievances. Maybe it was a moment of clarity, or maybe it was the six-pack of Coors Light we shared, but we had an epiphany. We were going about this whole domestic help thing all wrong. We hatched a genius plan, and experiment of sorts that would be sure to result in domestic bliss. We decided that each of us would try a different approach to getting help around the house, and we would report our level of success to the other, and make adjustments accordingly. It went something like this: I would try a “honey-do” list of sorts. I would take a bright and colorful piece of paper, and write down some household tasks and tape the list to the fridge. The logic here was that my husband, being a type-A personality, couldn’t resist the sight of a list of tasks confronting him on our fridge, and would cherish the accomplishment of crossing things off that list. My best friend’s approach would be a bit different—positive reinforcement. She would ask her husband to finish a few tasks around the house (no begging, no pleading), and whenever he finished that task, he would be “rewarded” (use your imagination here). We decided that our great experiment would be one of unlocking the secrets of the male persuasion: would our husbands savor a sense of accomplishment more, or were they simpler creatures, tantalized by sheer bribery?
The first days of our experiment were met with great success. I cleared off the fridge of all of its mosaic patchwork of pictures, leftover wedding shower invitations and random recipes. I printed a list of household tasks needing some serious attention and it became the sole inhabitant of the front of our fridge, blazing its message of domesticity gaily across the room. I printed it on lime green paper in a cheerful font, and excitedly pointed it out to my husband when he came home from work one day. He seemed amenable to his honey-do list beaming from the fridge, and the first few days he threw himself into the tasks with gusto. He did revel in a sense of accomplishment, and I plied him ample praise and appreciation for his help around the house. Our house was a virtual beacon of domestic equality…for a while.
Back at my best friend’s house, she reported similar results. She had asked her husband to help with a few select chores around the house, and the first time he capitulated and participated in cooking dinner with her, she handsomely rewarded him with a romantic evening for two. She called a few days into our experiment to tell me that her husband was now rushing home after work each day, and actually inquired as to what she might need help with around the house. “It’s amazing,” she whispered conspiratorially, “he’s vacuuming, he’s doing dishes, he’s folding laundry…all with a smile on his face!”
My best friend and I felt vindicated, and quite clever, actually. We now had achieved working models of equality in our homes, and we were less exhausted and put out in the remaining household tasks we engaged in each day. Life was good.
Alas, time changes all things, and a mere month into our experiment, things took a quite different turn. One day, I noticed the number of tasks on my honey-do list that were being crossed off was rapidly diminishing. I prodded my husband gently, asking him if he had noticed there were still many things on our list that needed attention. He diverted his attention, temporarily, from ESPN and grunted a response akin to “I’ll get to it later.” I sensed trouble brewing.
Conversely, over at my best friend’s house, she was reporting signs of fatigue. She called me one afternoon, and sighed distractedly, “He comes home every day now, and when he takes out the trash or picks up his laundry, he asks what he gets for it. I’m starting to feel like a hooker. I have to pay up for the smallest tasks, or he becomes impossible…I’m not sure how long I can keep this up.” Her voice had taken on the pitch of a desperate woman. I reported my similar troubles. We were beginning to have doubts.
Tragically, within a few weeks we had to brand our experiment a failure. My honey-do list had, somewhat symbolically, fallen off of the fridge a number of times, and was now wretchedly tattooed with grease splotches and most disturbingly, a boot print resembling my husband’s foot size. It no longer resembled its former cheerful self. After weeks of inattention, I put the list out of its misery and into the recycling bin.
Similarly, my best friend had abandoned her positive reinforcement system out of sheer exhaustion. She felt that, in the end, it was less energy to do the work herself than have to “pay” her husband for it. She dramatically declared her days of prostitution were over.
So, years later, I still have no good answers in my fight for domestic equality. I am still the primary cook, laundress, and toilet scrubber. I do however win the occasional battle for my husband to clean the cat litter or unload the dishwasher. I’m only slightly ahead of where my mother was at my age, but progress is progress, right?