eat a peanut butter and pickle sandwich

I was watching Food network and the cooking channel and it got me into this mood where I just wanted to try something different, but simple. SO I’m eating a half a sandwich of pickles cheese mustard and mayo, and I thought, “What else would be good with pickle?” I looked that up, and I came up with peanut butter. So I anxiously tried it. It was SO good, easily my new favorite sandwich and peanut butter and pickles is a great low-cal snack! DO it!!! haha 10 months ago

i discovered it by accident. first mix honey nut cheerios with peanut butter, then smear it on top of a kosher dill pickle. it’s fabulous and really does stimulate a unique combination of taste buds.

p.s. you can use regular cheerios too, but honey nut makes it sweeter. 3 years ago

It is really good. I love ‘em. Enjoy! 4 years ago

When I was in 7th grade, my Utah studies teacher musta been high or sumthin, cuz she offered us extra credit if we would eat a PB&P sandwich….they totally rock my polka dot socks! E-z-ist 50 points i’ve ever made. I almost felt like a geek for enjoying extra credit…almost. =] 4 years ago

My siblings & I have been eating peanut butter and pickle sandwiches (always kosher dill, anything else is gross, lol) ofor over 40 years. I will have this as a meal or a midnight snack and often crave it in the middle of the night. It is my guilty pleasure. My friends think it is weird but when I try to convince them how tasty it really is they just make that funny scrunched up face like someone just farted. I try to explain to them the anatomy behind the tongue: sweet, sour, salty, bitter, and umami (savory) taste receptor sites on the tongue. They usually get a glazed look in their eye, shake their head in utter disgust while at the same time saying that they could never imagine even having the resembleance of az desire for such a bizarre concoction.

This is why you should try this at least once before you move this into the arena strictly reserved for pregnant women. Much like salty and sweet together is quite tastey (such as kettle corn, honey glazed ham, or really good melons with salt) so PB&P stimulates the salty and sour sensations simultaneously, a combination that does not occur often but can be experienced with salt and vinegar potato chips. If you like that flavor of chips, then rest assured you will like PB&P even more.

Signed a true aficionado 4 years ago

I’m not sure where I got the idea to try a PB & pickle sandwich. However, they are good. Creamy peanut butter and dill pickles.

I think I may go make myself one right now.

P.S. I’ve also tried a Mayo & pickles sandwich. This idea I got from a couple friends. It’s an okay sandwich, but not as good as PB & Pickle. 4 years ago

My mom and grandma do this and i thought it was wierd for years… and then I tried it. I actually ahve cravings for them at times!

Use Jiff and dill pickles. 4 years ago

I’ve always wanted to try this. I read about it in a book somewhere, but it sounds kind of gross, so I haven’t been that brave yet. 5 years ago