IM reading the silmarillion
:D 7 years ago
People doing thisSee everyone
...the more you’ll enjoy the in-depth studies found in many of the manuscript collections, so heads up! Not everything was just a tale in Tolkien. He remains my favorite author to this day, though, and one of the proudest moments in my life was to see that a paper of mine on astronomy in Tolkien that was cowritten with a friend was cited by Christopher Tolkien in one of those collections. A wonderful feeling. 8 years ago
So I’ve officially finished reading “The Lord Of The Rings” for the tenth time.
The Scouring Of The Shire is one of my favourite chapters in the book, and was kind of sorry it wasn’t dealt with in Jackson’s film.
I liked it because, when I got to it in the reading of the novel, I was like, “Good grief, dem done fight all kind of battle, they reach home and must fight too?”
I guess the reason why I like this chapter so much, is because the dialogue is hilarious for one, and how in dealing with the ‘Sharkey’s ruffians’, you could SEE the change that had come over Frodo, Sam, Merry and Pippin. Pippin finds his leadership, and the beginning of his authority for when he becomes “The Took”, Merry also shows the beginning of his coming into his status as a Brandybuck. Frodo, who although he never pulls his sword during the Battle of Bywater, you can see the beginning of the damage that was caused by the quest to destroy the Ring. Sam, finally starts to make headway and succeeds in wooing and marrying Rosie Cotton.
I always wonder about the people who watched the film, and said that it should have ended when Aragorn was crowned in Minas Tirith.
I always say, “That would have been so easy… too easy.”
For me, Tolkien’s extension, telling the story beyond the climax of the fighting and the destruction of the ring was necessary.
He had spent so much time building up the power of Ring over Frodo, and how in the end, at the very end, the Ring CLAIMED Frodo, it would have been too pat to just allow Frodo to go back to the Shire and live happily ever after. I don’t think it would have worked in the story.
The long time it took for the Ring to work on Frodo, rub down his resitance and to finally, at the moment of it’s greatest peril, exert such a force as to erode Frodo’s control, NEEDED to be resolved. Because although Frodo resisted long, he certainly did not last as long as Bilbo, and used the ring even less, he did ULTIMATELY give in.
And in giving in, he mourned the Ring after his passing. This is why he couldn’t find peace in the Shire when he returned. It’s a noble thing he did, but even he knew that the quest was going to claim him, and if it wasn’t for Same and Gollum, he would have been altogether lost in every sense.
I love The Scouring of The Shire. In may ways, this chapter is the climax of the story, even though it’s very much a “wrapping it up” part of the story.
I read quite slowly this rounds. There have been other times when I read the whole story in a week or so, but this time I took my time and read very, very slowly.
I enjoyed it as always…. will probably read it for the 11th time this time next year.
Next: The Silmarillion (when I get my books from Trini.) 8 years ago
The Alliance has marched on the Black Gate, to draw Sauron’s eye away.
Frodo and Sam have just left the Tower of Cirith Ungol, and descended into Mordor.
Poor Frodo is tired, and so is Sam, but they haven’t run out of food or water yet, and are about to meet a cruel test that will slip them even deeper into Mordor.
I love this story… I don’t care how many times I read it, it’s always like the first time… 8 years ago
I have been reading fairly slowly this time, because I’ve been so focussed on work and finishing projects, and distracted by love… but Faramir and Frodo have been talking in Ithilien. Gollum has been captured and released to Frodo’s care, Faramir and Company are about to part ways with Frodo and Company. Frodo is about to take the paths of Cirith Ungol. 8 years ago
I have begun reading The Lord Of The Rings for the tenth time. Bliss… I haven’t read it since about this time last year, so I guess I am due.
Frodo is in Bag End, hemming and hawing about leaving and Gandalf is still with him.
I am once again slipping into Tolkien’s world, and I already know it’s rich and vibrant. It’s like going to see a good friend. 9 years ago