...my most recent entries. I put a lot of thought into them, and really don’t wish to see them buried. Why is that? Often, we hear of the tragic human price of this current conflict, which I cannot minimize in any manner. On the other hand, each conflict inevitably brings with it a price, such as it is. Anyhow, for those who wish to read them…my thoughts.
What would a domestic enemy be? ...it would be that person, who takes an active role, treasonously, against the Constitution.
To be honest, and I quote Heinlein here, the determination of who an enemy is, isn’t my decision. That’s for heads who are older and wiser than I. The military is an extension of a nation’s foreign policy. Can I have an opinion? Sure, I just don’t have the authority to necessarily ACT on it. The Officer Corps is traditionally apolitical as a profession, a small price to pay for the priviledge of serving. Again, I have an opinion, but that doesn’t count for much – I don’t decide where and when to apply force, just the how, and really only on an operational and tactical level.
Before this goes further, and I’ll admit I’m leery of the response, “don’t you think Bush is doing that with troops in Iraq,” I think I should clarify my point of view a little more.
We have had, since 2002, which is when OIF kicked off, just a hair over 3000 US deaths in Iraq. That’s over a period of FIVE years. Given the fact that troops rotate in and out on 12 month cycles (far less for the USAF), and assuming we have 150K troops there at any given time, I’m calculating roughly 750K troops have cycled through the entire theater of operations. Take out 25% for slop and replacement (some have been more than once) and we’re down to 563K. 3/563,000 is far, far less than 1%. More numbers: in 1999, 41,611 Americans lost their lives to automobile accidents on domestic highways. In 2001, it was 42,166. 3K over five years, 42K in one year, yet oddly enough, we don’t shut down the Interstate system. I know for a fact we’re doing good things for the Iraqi people, as I’ve heard too many eyewitness stories about it that don’t make headlines here.
Now, a domestic enemy – a traitor. Anyone who takes an active role in destroying the Constitution.
I won’t classify the current President in that category. I’ll even meet most folks halfway and label him, at worst, “irresponsible.” Personally, I have yet to see this president break the law, or take measures against the Constitution. I just don’t see it.
The current passport I hold is, I’m fairly certain, my fourth issued. #3 was issued at the Berlin Consulate when my parents lived there the second time, #2 was the official brown passport when parents were stationed there, teaching, in the 80s, and the first was the tourist version of #2. :) I totally understand the feeling of being more a citizen of the world, rather than just a US citizen. When I returned from my senior year in college abroad, returning to an “american” way of life was not easy. It still isn’t.
In terms of the awful toll this conflict has brought, I am of two minds – one being a circumstance of my profession, which is a choice. I chose the profession of arms, which is what it is. I don’t see anything dishonorable with the profession, realizing that it’s “need” is a function of the human condition, such as it is.
The Officer mindset does tend to express the price of the conflict in terms of US lives, it’s how we think and fight. What I tend not to mention is the price the families pay, while fathers, brothers, sons, mothers, daughters and sisters are off in foreign lands. I saw friends and family (my twin returned from his tour with the Army National Guard in Mosul in Dec 05) go to Iraq and Afghanistan and return. The whole time, I have seen the price paid by families torn asunder – some weather the separation, some do not, which is nothing short of tragic.
Personally, I’d rather not go, and rather not be fighting. Honestly, I didn’t choose this profession because I like the destruction it causes. I know none of my brother Officers would have this war going on either, given the choice. We are the ones who must go. I know very few Soldiers who want to go fight. We are all volunteers, and the fighting comes with the profession of arms.
The cost of this entire conflict has been awful in human terms on both sides. Clash of ideas, clash of religions, clash of cultures, clash of civilizations, call it what you will. I know the price has been steep for all involved, regardless of nationality, race or religion.
“The war on terrorism is a war on ideas….and when we fight fire with fire…we just get a lot of ashes and destruction…I would like to see us figure out how to distinguish the fire…
It seems you would too. Thanks for that, if I am understanding you correctly.”
You are. With the state our world is in, I don’t see the conflict ending soon, unfortunately. Sadly, I think we will have several generations, who will know nothing but a “war on terrorism.” That said, I don’t hold out a lot of hope for a peaceful resolution. Call it pessimism, call it Man’s fallen nature, I just am not hopeful. To me, both cultures in conflict here are pretty intolerant of other points of views.
There you all have it, in all its glory.
A further twist, since I seem to be on a roll today. I am an Army Officer, teaching Soldiers to become Officers. Therefore, I do an inordinate amount of thinking and pontificating about the very nature of the profession and its implications. Folks, keep in mind that most Army Officers today, in fact all, have a college degree, many hold one, if not two, Master’s degrees. Many also have a PhD or equivalent (I’m starting my EdD as soon as C&GS is done). Officers are not low-brow killers. Many of them fit in as easily in mudholes and firing ranges as they do at a black tie affair in any major city in the world. I have a friend who looked forward to his year in Afghanistan, as it would be an excellent opportunity to get some great poetry written.
Some of my fellow Officers support the cause of the conflict and some do not, it’s that simple. In all cases, we all go when ordered and do the best we can once there. One of the sacrifices we make for the Profession of Arms, is we abdicate, on some level, the right to choose. If I’m ordered to go to Iraq, that’s an order. I don’t have a choice in the matter, providing I want to remain in the service of my country.
Above all, please remember one thing, if nothing else. We serve our country. We don’t do it for the gore, the violence, or the “priviledge” to be away from loved ones for extended periods. We do it, ultimately, out of a love for country. We’re not psychotic, nor do we wish to inflict an inordinate amount of pain and suffering for the sake of inflicting it. Understand this, however: when it comes to protecting my family and my Soldiers, I will do whatever I must.